- 河流 (The River)
10/22/26 (Thurs)
Tsai Ming-liang’s 1997 film, which immediately preceded The Hole, is considered one of his signature works. It deals with Tsai’s usual theme of alienation and loneliness but in a more serious vein than Vive L’Amour and The Hole from the same period.
The film explores three characters. One is a young man, Xiao Kang (played by Tsai’s muse Lee Kang-sheng), who, accompanying a friend to her work on a film set, is cajoled into playing the part of a dead body floating in the dirty Tansui River, a role that becomes prophetic. (The film director, played by real-life Hong Kong director Ann Hui, praises him as being better than the initial mannequin.) He subsequently experiences a debilitating neck pain that becomes increasingly severe over the course of the film, which, though never made explicit, we are led to attribute to the polluted waters.
Another is an old man (Miao Tien) in a stale marriage who spends time sneaking into a gay bathhouse, where he lies in a room waiting for guys to approach him. Elsewhere, we spot him at one point at a McDonald’s eyeing a handsome kid cruising the halls, eventually pursuing him into the toilets. He interacts briefly with Xiao Kang when the latter falls off his motorcycle.
The third is an elevator woman (Lu Yi-ching), interacting with customers only as they get on and off. She is having a loveless affair with a distributor of porn videos. She treats him tenderly, but he is dismissive of her attempts at intimacy or even normal conversation, leaving her frustrated and lonely.
It is only well into the movie that we realize that these three are a married couple and their son. Communication among them is sparse, though both parents try to help the son as he falls into despair and ultimately depression. The mother rubs balm onto his neck, the father holds the son’s neck up as they ride a motorcycle together (something that Tsai actually did when Lee suffered a similar injury – he was surprised that people saw the scene as amusing), and both rush to the hospital where their son is bashing his head against a wall wishing he were dead. But their interaction is limited in all the things that matter, with no small talk or common interests. They eat alone and pursue their separate interests. The father and son are both unemployed, and neither show much interest in changing that, not a formula for mental peace. That leaves the mother as the breadwinner. The mother does try to help both her spouse and child but is met with indifference by both, perhaps because of their feelings of inadequacy.
As the boy’s woes deepen with the pain, they try everything: doctors, acupuncture (a harrowing scene shows needles being inserted into his fingers), chiropractors, hot presses, shamans, and a massage by the mother with what appears to be her vibrator. The boy never seems to connect his troubles with the river, though it seems clear enough to us. He is trapped in his deteriorating body, just as the father and mother are similarly trapped in their own ways.
Water as usual with Tsai plays an important role here. The river, obviously, but also the leaky roof in the family’s home, stemming from the apartment above (another similarity with The Hole). The father creatively diverts the flow to his garden rather than fix the problem, but the water finally bursts into a flood (just as the father is relieving his son at the sauna), which the mother ultimately and tearfully deals with on her own. Along with the storms at the end, water is not a healing balm but a destructive force.
Sex is a running theme, all of it as transient as it is unsatisfying. Xiao Kang has an intense quickie with his old female friend (who then disappears from the film), the father has anonymous sex with whoever enters his room and engages with him, and the mother is reduced to rubbing provocatively against her sleeping friend while imagining something more. There’s a heartbreaking moment where she is watching a Japanese couple go at it in one of his porn videos, longing for the human touch that her affair is not providing. The low point comes in an extraordinary extended scene in the darkness of the bathhouse, when the father unknowingly connects with his son (who is presumably looking for intimacy of any kind in his eroded state) and gives him a hand job. When the light comes on, the embarrassed father slaps his son angrily, but in the very next scene, he is seen at the side of a bed as his son sleeps, calling the shaman to ask if the gods have answered their prayers (they did, but negatively). When the father leaves the room, the son gets up, walks to the balcony and briefly out of the scene before reemerging – and the film ends.
It is an unsettling finish, providing no conclusion to any of the stories. The three characters are all as solitary as they were at the beginning, and the film leaves no hope for the future. It is a far cry from the transforming moment at the end of The Hole. Tsai relies mainly on long shots and extended sequences including peripheral activities like eating or ironing, which feel like unedited shots of real life rather than neatly set-up scenes. The highlight is the long, unhurried encounter between the father and son in the sauna, the father’s face kept hidden from us and the boy until after the climax is achieved. Great filmmaking. The following sequence with the mother dealing with the downpour is also masterful.
All three of the principals give solid performances: Lee with his twisted neck, Miao with his perennially forlorn look, Lu with her mournful yearning. Other Tsai stalwarts can be seen throughout, including Lee’s costar from The Hole in a small role. While hardly an optimistic film, it is exceptionally moving and memorable. Strongly recommended.