Cyrano (2021 film)

  • Cyrano

10/1/26 (Thurs)

Lot Airlines didn’t offer much in the way of films, but this one caught my eye. I had seen the disappointing Adrian Lester stage version in London a few months back and the peerless Depardieu film version last week, but this one, with the diminutive Peter Dinklage, seemed a unique variation. I figured they would use his size rather than his nose as his source of despair, and was imagining especially the insults that Dinklage could conjure up in the first fight scene. Dinklage is a terrific actor, and this seemed an ideal role for his talents.

Sadly, as with Lester’s version, they weren’t courageous enough to push that far enough. The film was content to let the visuals do the work for them, letting the dialogue reflect that only in a minor way. Dinklage is an engaging presence and a more-than-capable Cyrano, but the script lets him down.

The biggest problem, however, was the limp music and especially the insipid lyrics. The entire show revolves around the hero’s command of language and poetry. Would he really say, “Everybody knows / I’m much more than a freak” or, more laughably, “What I wouldn’t do to get some sleep / But we’re taking fire”? The same goes for Roxanne, who is turned on specifically by her love of the dialogue and letters delivered (she believes) by the handsome Christian. She sings, “I want someone to die for / Write poems and cry for” and “I’d give anything for someone to say to me / That no matter how bad it gets…” The original Cyrano is practically a musical anyway with its poetic prose, but this cheapens it badly. That’s not helped by the amateurish choreography, notably Christian’s number.

The film adds new scenes at the opening to put greater focus on Roxanne, presumably to give her more “agency”. It just drags the drama down to television level. Also, it again features black actors playing whiteface in 17th-century France, including Christian and his friend. That all makes this hard to take seriously. Moreover, it turns the supreme final scene into mush.

On the other hand, some of the dialogue is deftly rhymed, giving some sense of the original. The setting and costumes are also true to the period, aided by lush cinematography, including a great scene in the snow.

Dinklage’s strong performance makes me wish he could play the role without the poor music dragging him down. Christian was excellent as well within the limits that the unfortunate script allows. Roxanne isn’t very well cast – I guess if we’re supposed to accept Christian as white (allowing for the time period), we can imagine her as a knockout – and her performance is at best conventional.

Overall, a waste of great talent, weighed down not only by an execrable score but by the very idea of turning this into a musical (opera might be a different story). No one has succeeded in several attempts, including a big Broadway musical that has never been revived, but it needs better than the AI-generated stuff here. Pitiful.

Leave a Reply