A Judgment in Stone (La cérémonie)

  • La cérémonie (A Judgment in Stone)

9/15/26 (Tue)

Claude Chabrol’s 1995 suspense film, drawn from the same source as Genet’s The Maids (1947), is a frustrating work. A well-to-do French family hires a woman as a maid in their comfortable countryside home. The maid, a silent and ambiguous figure (the Japanese title is The Silent Woman 沈黙の女), befriends another working-class woman who works at the post office. The latter is particularly resentful of the middle class and higher, a view that gradually poisons the maid’s mind as well. Both discover (in unlikely fashion) that the other has been accused of a high-profile murder in the past and acquitted. Whatever the truth of those cases – and we’re never quite sure – it casts an ominous shadow.

Though the family members are perfectly decent people, such as offering to give the maid driving lessons and pay for her eye doctor and reading glasses, their very ability to do so is taken as condescending regardless of their intentions. The postal worker opens the man’s mail, disparages one family’s clothing donations for the poor, and makes herself a general nuisance. The maid, who has claimed to have extremely poor vision, turns out to be illiterate, discovered only when the family’s teenage daughter tries the glasses on. Having eavesdropped on the daughter’s private phone conversation, the maid threatens to reveal that the daughter is pregnant if she should disclose her reading disability. That attempt at blackmail along with other transgressions lead to her dismissal, though the father generously allows her to stay an extra week and pay everything he owes. When the postal worker comes to help the maid pack, the two start playing around with the father’s guns, and one thing leads to another. In an ironic ending, the postal worker is killed in her car in the darkness when a priest, no less, bashes into her, and the maid quietly escapes as the police listen to the tape recorder that the postal worker had stolen from the family – which has, unbeknownst to the killers, recorded the entire murder.

I was disgusted by the film at first, especially the final 20 minutes or so. The family did nothing wrong and extended every kindness to the maid, so their fate objectively was entirely undeserved. Then I recalled the recent affair where Luigi Mangione murdered an insurance executive in cold blood as the face of what he saw as an unfair system and, closer to home, the vagrant who rang the doorbell at a random household in my neighborhood and fatally stabbed the old man who answered simply because he thought that it was a rich area. While neither of those cases in any way justifies murder – both, if found guilty, should be drawn and quartered in the most painful way possible – I do understand the brooding resentment that even normal citizens feel toward the demeaning attitude of the rich, unintended though that might be. I’m just not sure how the family should have behaved: should they not have hired a maid at all? Walled themselves off from the poor rather than give them jobs?

One scene that stood out for me was the car repair incident. The postal worker is stuck on the side of the road due to mechanical issues. Mélinda, the daughter of the household, happens to pass and stops to help. She opens the hood and works on the battery.

Mélinda: (lightly) Don’t expect any miracles, but I’m good with cars.

Worker: Not me. (wanders to side and stares at field) Poetry’s my thing.

N: (working on car) Really? You try getting published?

W: Not yet. I’m going to wait a while.

M: Try starting the engine.

W: (stares at field for moment, then enters car) It works.

M: (closes hood) The battery must have a short circuit. (looks at oil-stained hands)

W: Thanks a lot.

M: Have you got a rag?

W: I have a hankie. (takes hankie from pocket)

M: (wipes her hands, throws hankie back in car) Thanks.

W: Thanks again.

M: No problem. If I were you, I’d see a mechanic. (drives off)

I was surprised to find that most reviewers criticize the way the daughter throws the hankie back in the car, nearly hitting the postal worker in the face. They feel that the former is belittling the woman. In fact, she has gone out of her way to stop her car, get down and dirty, and fix the battery, while the postal worker barely acknowledges the gesture, babbling about poetry and not even offering her hankie until asked. It is telling that the postal worker fancies herself a poet but does nothing to make that happen, while it is the well-to-do daughter who can open the hood of a car, identify the problem, and repair it. Is this really a problem of rich and poor, or is there something more fundamental? What exactly is the source of the postal worker’s resentment?

The daughter, as noted, is also the one who discovers that the maid is illiterate when she tries on the latter’s glasses and realizes that they are blank lenses – the problem is not that the maid can’t see but that she can’t read. She apologizes to the maid for not realizing and offers to teach her or send her to a specialist in Paris. Rather than show gratitude, the maid threatens her, spitting, “I’m not the bitch. You are. Mind your own business.” Which one is being arrogant? The lower-class party is again uninterested in bettering herself, so what exactly is the family supposed to do about it? The opening line of the source novel, A Judgment in Stone, is, “Eunice Parchman killed the Coverdale family because she could not read or write.” That would imply that she’s driven by shame rather than class issues, though perhaps those feelings are mixed. I’m not sure what to think about Chabrol’s claim that this is the “last Marxist film”.

I was interested to find that the French title, which I assumed meant simply “the ceremony”, is in fact archaic slang for ritualistic preparations prior to execution by guillotine. I’m not sure what that has to do with events here, but it’s a creative touch. Google tells me that it “also satirizes the rigid, unyielding social performances and etiquette of the upper-middle class”, which is pretty bogus. (The title of the source novel evidently means that the murder, which remember was based on an actual event, was carved in stone, i.e., inevitable. Is that so?)

For all its thematic issues, the film is beautifully made, boasting spectacular performances all around. Isabelle Huppert, Sandrine Bonnaire, Jacqueline Bisset, Jean-Pierre Cassel – all are at the peak of their powers, absolutely perfect. Virginie Ledoyen was also superb as the daughter. Ensemble acting at its best.

The film raises difficult questions, but it seems reviewers are drawing the wrong answers. Recommended.

Leave a Reply