Lalka (film)

  • Lalka (film)

10/3/26 (Sat)

Lalka (The Doll), released here in Warsaw just days ago, is based on a famous 19th-century novel, evidently considered one of the great works of Polish literature. This, the work’s second large-scale film rendition (the first is highly regarded), boasts a star-studded cast in one of the most expensive Polish films ever made. Coincidentally, a Netflix miniseries also began recently, and a stage version is playing at Poland’s National Theater. So the piece is having its day. As the novel is an epic of over a thousand pages, the film is presumably cut significantly. But I have the advantage of knowing nothing about it.

The setting is late 19th-century Poland. A man has survived the horrors of the Polish uprising and has become a fabulously wealthy merchant. He is modest and giving, but his generosity is sometimes taken by jealous people as calculating. He is in love with a beautiful daughter in the landed aristocracy, but she shows little interest. The family is far above him in social status, but as they are struggling financially, he hopes he can change the girl’s mind by showing kindness to them. However, their small-mindedness makes it seem to her that she is being sold off. (Her character is generally seen as the titular doll, a plaything used by others, though the author insisted that he was referring to a small incident where the merchant gives a doll to a poor child.) Her stubbornness blinds her to the merchant’s genuine feeling for her, and she is miserable in the end. He also wonders ultimately what he has been living for as his wealth has not brought him satisfaction. His ending is tragic. The family is also ruined by its greed. That is, neither wealth nor poverty has led anyone to happiness.

The first half is a deft comedy of manners, while the second takes a turn to the serious. The characters are wonderfully drawn, including even minor relatives and acquaintances. There is a dubious sequence where a scientist, attempting to create a metal lighter than air, shows a gem he engineered that impossibly floats off the ground. His theory came true many years later in the airplane, and while the author couldn’t have imagined that, surely they could have tweaked things to imply research toward that end. What they came up with was dumb.

The cast was spectacular all around, led by the merchant (composed on the outside but torn on the inside, afraid to let his emotions get the better of him) and Isabel, the woman he loved. An American version would give the latter more agency – and the Netflix show probably does just that – but this felt more realistic for the times.

Great camerawork and location work, expert lighting. Enjoyable throughout despite its long running time. I hope it gets proper attention overseas.

Leave a Reply