3/18/21 (Thurs)
An amazing film of 1934 by John Stahl based on a novel published the previous year. Bea (Claudette Colbert) is a widowed mother who has taken over her husband’s maple syrup sales route, doing what she can to keep food on the table for her small daughter. Delilah (an unforgettable Louise Beavers), a black domestic, shows up at the door having mistaken the address on a want ad, but manages to talk Bea into letting her work for just room and board for her and her own grade-school daughter. Struck by Delilah’s delicious pancakes, Bea turns her syrup and the pancakes into big business, becoming extremely wealthy in the process. She scrupulously sets aside a half-share for Delilah, viewing her as an equal business partner. But Delilah’s only ambition is to care for her beloved daughter along with Bea’s household. When Bea suggests that Delilah buy her own home with her earnings, the latter panics, thinking she is being thrown out. She begs to continue living as a domestic with Bea, who has little choice but to agree.
As their girls grow up, each mother faces a dilemma. In the less persuasive story, Bea has finally found her dream man in the form of a hunky ichthyologist (they apparently exist, at least in this film) but discovers that her daughter has fallen for him as well. That is resolved in melodrama. Meanwhile, Delilah’s light-skinned daughter has been able to pass as white and, having grown up with Bea’s daughter, has essentially taken on a white identity. As a young woman, fearing exposure of her black heritage, she brutally rejects her shocked mother (“I don’t know this woman. Does she look like my mother?”) and walks out. That is resolved in tragedy. Delilah’s experience lifts the film into another dimension.
Continue reading →